How Successful Was The First New Deal Essay

Success Of The New Deal Essay

Success of the New Deal

During 1929 many people invested in the stock market, this led to the
stock becoming less and less valuable, this eventually led to the Wall
Street Crash. The current Republican President, Herbert Clark Hoover
was not seen to be doing enough so he was succeeded By President
Franklin Delano Roosevelt' (FDR) , who would end the depression with
his 'New Deal'. Roosevelt holds the unique distinction of being
elected four times by the people of America. Roosevelt's place in
American history has been fixed due to the New Deal but also because
he rose to the highest position in Americadespite having a crippling
cardiovascular illness. In his first 100 days he passed masses of laws
to get the U.S out of the depression. The 3 aims of the New Deal were
Relief, Recovery and Reform.

In my opinion the New Deal could have been far more successful if
Roosevelt had chose to continue his level of investment, maybe if he
even increased it. Roosevelt stopped 'priming the pump' and this led
to the 'Roosevelt Recession'. I believe that by 1941 The New Deal
could have succeeded in completely reviving the U.S economy, and it
would not have taking the Second World War to end the depression, had
it not been for FDR stopping his spending. The alphabet agencies could
have done better than give people useless jobs. Roosevelt also did
little to help farmers and black people who were already bad off
before the depression. Farmers were not well off because of the tariff
wars, and the 'dustbowl'. The tenant farmers suffered the most, as
they didn't own any land and the black people who were suffering
because of their lack of civil rights at the time. The New Deal did
succeed in lowering employment to a degree, and partially reversed the
spiral of depression, and before he lowered the level of spending the
economy was well on its way to the pre-crash levels.

By 1941 the 'New Deal' had both its successes and its failures. FDR
poured tax payers money to reverse the 'spiral of depression', which
was known as 'pump priming'. He had used the 'alphabet agencies' to
use get the skilled and unskilled unemployed workforce to work on
federal funded projects. The Public Work's administration (PWA) built
roads, bridges hospitals and schools. This was intended to give the
workforce more money so they could spend more if they spent more there
would be more demand for products and so more jobs, and therefore the
government would recoup their losses in the added tax, so the economy
would recover. This was successful as it helped the economy to recover
and it also built much needed public services. The Tennessee valley
authority did help farmers by regenerating the 'dustbowl'. The
'Dustbowl' was regenerated by building hydro-electric power stations;
using flood control for soil conservation, the...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

Evaluation Of The New Deal Essay

693 words - 3 pages Franklin D. Roosevelt brought the new deal into American life in the early thirties. Its purpose was to overcome the depression. Following the depression there were many programs and acts to help the nation recover from the depression. The "forgotten Americans" were the citizens who needed the new deal to benefit their poverty-stricken way of life. These people were the blacks, women, immigrants, and the many people who suffered from...

The Features of the New Deal

3987 words - 16 pages The Features of the New Deal Roosevelt was elected in 1932 after the former president Hoover. Roosevelt's New Deal was a group of different projects to pull America out of the Depression, and back into the economic boom of the 1920's. The New Deal consisted of direct government action which followed Rooselvelt's campaign based on fireside chats, the establishment of alphabet agencies and the pursuit of new social and...

The Main Features of the New Deal

2577 words - 10 pages The Main Features of the New Deal The New Deals were a series of Acts and schemes which Roosevelt hoped would pull America out of the depression. Roosevelt decided to tackle the economic problems before he did anything else because he knew that a strong and reliable money system would build up confidence in the Americans, which would act as a foundation for the American economy. In 1933 Roosevelt proved to the Americans...

The Impact of Roosevelt's New Deal

2274 words - 9 pages Look deep within United States history to find its most significant molding element and one will find that its source stemmed from a great national crisis. At its highest extent, nearly one-fourth of its labor force was unemployed and American confidence in itself was deeply shaken. It is in studying the Great Depression and President Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s New Deal, that America’s most significant influential event can be found. The New...

Main Features of The New Deal

6117 words - 24 pages Main Features of The New Deal In 1929, the stock market collapsed causing a worldwide economic depression, destroying America’s economy with many people losing their life savings therefore thrusting them into unemployment and poverty. Unemployment reached highs of over 13 million whilst the GNP for the country reached as low as $58 billion, compared to the $100 billion+ pre depression figures, because demand and...

The New Deal

3647 words - 15 pages Through out the history of the United States and the world for that matter, there have been many ideas and laws that were considered revolutionary at time, meaning they were thought to be groundbreaking and completely new. However, this conception is often a mistake; many of these ideas are simply evolutions of previous and forgotten notions. This means that they were not truly avant-garde but actually just older ideas that changed and developed...

The New Deal

880 words - 4 pages Sierra BrownRomeroTest 2, Question 4Hist. 175October 27, 2014The New DealThe New Deal effected Americans across the nation in many ways that were not always positive. Men and women, white and black Americans, and tenant farmers and industrial workers were all seeking better treatment and opportunities from the American government and hoped that the New Deal reform programs would...

The New Deal

603 words - 2 pages Throughout history there have been many different opinions about government regulation. Because the relative greed of businesses in terms of profit margins and little interest in the increase of wages and positive working environments played a role in causing the Great Depression, President Franklin Roosevelt implemented a set of policies known as the New Deal. The New Deal attempted to provide recovery and relief from the Great Depression...

The New Deal - 1595 words

1595 words - 6 pages The New Deal a) In 1933, the new president of America, Franklin D Roosevelt, introduced The New Deal. He did this because of America's economic depression at the time. For example, many banks went bankrupt in the Wall Street Crash. This happened because, during the economic many people got involved in the stock market, especially in speculation. This was where you would buy lots of stocks with a loan, then way for...

The New Deal

1584 words - 6 pages Do you know what it’s like to live in a cardboard home, starve, and raise a family in poverty? Unfortunately, most Americans in the 1930s went through this on a day-to-day basis. In 1929 the stock market crashed. Many people lost their life savings; they invested everything they owned in a failing stock market. The country was falling, everyone needed strong leadership and help from the government. Devastation and desperation started on...

The New Deal Reforms

1252 words - 5 pages The United States faced the worst economic downfall in history during the Great Depression. A domino effect devastated every aspect of the economy, unemployment rate was at an all time high, banks were declaring bankruptcy and the frustration of the general public led to the highest suicide rates America has ever encountered. In the 1930’s Franklin D Roosevelt introduced the New Deal reforms, which aimed to “reconcile democracy, individual...

FDR's New Deal Summary & Analysis

New Deal for a Depression That's Getting Old

Shortly after taking office in 1932, Roosevelt announced the "3 Rs" of the New Deal program to the American people—it was a package deal of relief, recovery, and reform. Just what the doctor ordered.

In the field of relief, the New Deal proved to be highly successful. Millions of Americans, unable to find work in an economy that was still badly broken four years into the Great Depression, might have literally starved to death if not for the government checks they earned by working for new agencies like the Civilian Conservation Corps and the Works Progress Administration. 

But in retrospect, it's kind of an obvious solution: if the private sector isn't making jobs, maybe the government should.

In terms of reform, the New Deal legacy may have been unmatched in American history. For better or worse, Roosevelt's program drastically altered the relationship between the capitalist market, the people, and their government, creating for the first time in this country's history, an activist state committed to providing individual citizens with a measure of security against the unpredictable turns of the market. 

Some believe this vast enlargement of the government's role in American society helped the country's long-run prospects. Others think we should allow the free market decide who starves. In any case, it remains a question of great political controversy to this day, but there can be no denying the magnitude of change wrought by FDR's presidency.

But when it came to recovery, the New Deal's performance lagged. It was certainly successful in both short-term relief, and in implementing long-term structural reform. However, as Roosevelt's political enemies fought him, the New Deal failed to end the Great Depression. Throughout the decade of the 1930s, unemployment remained brutally high, while economic growth remained painfully slow. 

Recovery only came about, at last, in Roosevelt's third term, when the heavy demands of mobilization for World War II finally restored the country to full employment, in essence by doing exactly what the New Deal had been attempting: providing government-created jobs. 

Ironically, then, Adolf Hitler probably did more to end the Great Depression in America than Franklin Roosevelt did. Yikes.

Still, despite failing in its most important objective, the New Deal forever changed the country. Roosevelt built a dominant new political coalition, creating a Democratic majority that lasted for half a century. The structural stability and social security provided by the New Deal's reforms underlay a postwar economic boom that many historians and economists have described as the "golden age of American capitalism." 

And Roosevelt permanently changed the American people's expectations of their presidents and their government, by actually, you know, doing stuff. Fortunately for later presidents, this expectation has since been rescinded.

0 thoughts on “How Successful Was The First New Deal Essay

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *